EFGAM Hawkishness Indicator

The EFGAM Hawkishness Indicator (EHI) aims to track the policy bias at central bank meetings. It does so by counting the number of times key terms such as “elevated”, “robust”, “high”, and “strong” are repeated in the published minutes of the meetings. The output is simply the number of times each key term appears.

Despite leaving interest rates unchanged for the second consecutive meeting, the Federal Reserve (Fed) sounded more hawkish in November than it did in September according to the EHI (see Chart 1).

Chart 1. EFGAM Fed Hawkishness Indicator

Source: Federal Reserve, LSEG Data & Analytics and EFGAM calculations. Data as at 23 November 2023.

Given the EHI fluctuates from meeting-to-meeting, it is informative to observe its broader trends. A notable relationship is that the EHI for the Fed has a 70% correlation with 12-month core PCE inflation.¹ It is therefore unsurprising that the decline in the EHI since July 2022 has been associated with a fall in core PCE inflation.

That the EHI for the Fed rose to 59 in November, and remained above its long-term median level of 44, highlights an important point.² Rates have likely peaked in the US, but while inflation remains significantly above its 2% target, the Fed is likely to continue to talk tough.

The same is true for the European Central Bank (ECB). The minutes from its October meeting also showed an increase in hawkishness according to the EHI, which rose from 89 to 99 (see Chart 2). The inclusion of the statement “It was deemed important for the Governing Council to avoid an unwarranted loosening of financial conditions” highlighted that the central bank was comfortable with markets expecting rates to stay higher for longer while inflation is above the 2% target.³

Chart 2. EFGAM ECB Hawkishness Indicator

Source: European Central Bank, LSEG Data & Analytics and EFGAM calculations. Data as at 23 November 2023.

While rates have likely also peaked for the ECB, the EHI remained well above its median level of 33.⁴ The indicator has an 84% correlation with core HICP inflation.⁵ If the disinflationary trend continues in the eurozone, one might expect the ECB’s tone to soften, and perhaps at a faster pace than for the Fed given the higher starting point.

Interestingly, the EHI for the Bank of England (BoE) declined at its November meeting, falling to 20 and below its long-term median level of 21 (see Chart 3).⁶ The indicator’s correlation with core CPI inflation is also lower than for the other two central banks, at 47%.⁷

Chart 3. EFGAM BoE Hawkishness Indicator

Source: Bank of England, LSEG Data & Analytics and EFGAM calculations. Data as at 23 November 2023.

The lower correlation could highlight the difficulty the Bank has in clearly communicating its thinking, with former and current Governors Mark Carney and Andrew Bailey both being likened to an “unreliable boyfriend”.

Despite the decline in the BoE EHI, which is only based on monetary policy meeting minutes, MPC members have sought to avoid loosening financial conditions in media appearances following the November meeting. Governor Bailey recently noted investors were placing “too much weight” on the sharp decline in inflation in October and that the BoE is “concerned” about the persistence of inflation.⁸ This highlights that the central bank’s baseline scenario also sees rates staying higher for longer.

In summary, the meeting-to-meeting volatility of the EHIs means that caution should be exercised when interpreting them. While the indicators have declined from their peaks last year, they remain elevated for the Fed and ECB. The EHI for the BoE has declined meaningfully, despite the Bank highlighting its baseline scenario of rates remaining higher for longer. All three central banks have an incentive to talk tough while inflation is high, to avoid financial market conditions easing and undoing some of the inflation fighting impact of higher policy rates.



¹ Fed EHI and core PCE inflation correlation measured on data from January 2010 to September 2023.
² Fed EHI Long-term median calculated on data from January 2010 to November 2023.
³ https://go.pardot.com/e/931253/ecb-mg23112340c9631bc7-en-html/3rz61/299904567/h/mp3wfyMbrenbl1HpaxiE6-oSyv7dh2n_lK7ji_z6SsQ
⁴ ECB EHI long-term median calculated on data from January 2015 to October 2023.
⁵ ECB EHI and core HICP inflation correlation measured on data from January 2015 to October 2023.
⁶ BoE long-term median calculated on data from January 2010 to November 2023.
⁷ BoE EHI and core CPI inflation correlation measured on data from January 2010 to October 2023.
⁸ https://go.pardot.com/e/931253/e8-745f-4267-898a-98c6c14057bd/3rz64/299904567/h/mp3wfyMbrenbl1HpaxiE6-oSyv7dh2n_lK7ji_z6SsQ